Sunday, December 21, 2008

Neil Gaiman on Hanukkah and Christmas

Thanks to Laura Gayle for the link!

Neil Gaiman writes about his family's Hanukkah/Christmas struggle and the kids' ultimate triumph.

At our house, we never would even think of having a tree. But I was surrounded by non-Jewish friends, so I got my yearnings out of my system by decorating my German friend Monica's tree and spending xmas day with them. Their traditions included drinking Henkel Trocken punch [the addition of frozen strawberries made it punch], listening to the ultimate irony -- Barbara Streisand singing xmas songs -- and general post-holiday sloth. Oh, and Monica's brother's rum balls...Martin could make a mean rum ball!

In my later high school years, I subbed in for a christian friend at her job, one day a year -- xmas, of course. It was at the nicest nursing home in London, Ontario, and all I had to do as receptionist was answer phones and deliver Poinsettia plants to the residents as they trickled in all day. So strange to have the non-residents say, "bless you for giving up your xmas!" to me, over and over, year after year. Everyone said that.

I spent the day doing the job, calling Monica's family to celebrate long-distance, and working my way through the previous year's worth of New Yorker Magazine cartoons, issue by issue. [Heaven.] At the end of my shift, I opened the special desk drawer, removed my pay envelope and went home to my tinsel-free family.

I never wanted not to be Jewish. Like Neil, I just wanted the bling in my house, too.

--> Bling achieved.

Labels:

Comments:
That sure is bling bling! And thank you (and Ysolda!) to let me know Neil Gaiman. By now I have read his Coraline and yes... I can't wait to see the film (btw, I'm from Amsterdam, The Netherlands).
 
Very "blingy". And if I look around my neighborhood... it seems as if the muslim familys were the first to get out the lights and setting up glittering trees in their gardens. Everybody likes bling!

(Except for me in my house, I stick with natural straw decoration and real candles, but thats another story.)
 
I love the Gaiman article. I stopped celebrating Christmas years ago and started celebrating the solstice instead with a solstice tree. (My family thought I was a bit nuts, I think, but they were kind of used to that...)

Your tree is adorable! Happy Solstice to you!
 
And now, if you wish, you can find all the bits and bobs of scrap yarn and knit yourself lots of tiny goodies to further bling-up your tree!

(I'm super jealous of your tree... I always wanted a tinsel tree!)
 
i grew up happy to be jewish, not missing the tree or anything. but as i got older i started to feel left out because for a week every year most of my friends just vanished to their families! it was a lonely time and it made me feel very left behind. now i'm married to a a lovely non-jew and his family includes me in their very low key christmas, and i even gave in and we a have tree, but it is covered in hot pink and purple glittery stuff and a perler bead star of david. he gets the tree, i get the bling!
 
Amy -

For years we begged for a Chunakah bush, my father wouldn't allow it. Maybe next year I'll knit the kids a Chanukah bush - wouldn't that be something? LOL.

HAPPY CHANUKAH!
 
My dad's whole side is Jewish (although most all of my immediate family is now Mormon, including my dad), but my dad has a while fake christmas tree that he decorates with blue and silver ornaments and calls his "Hanukkah Bush" :)

Happy Hanukkah, I lit my menorah last night and had friends over for dinner. The Noro scarf I am knitting smells like latkes ;)
 
Hang a few special (knitting) ornaments on it and like we do with our smaller tree, keep it up all year!
 
While I can understand your feelings, I do think you could show the courtesy of spelling out Christmas and not repeatedly using xmas.
 
I also used to work on Christmas. Only my customers would say, "I can't believe you are open. Is the owner a Jew?" Pretty funny at the time. Yes, the owner was a Jew, as was I. I was making quadruple time for working the holiday and he was making money hand over fist.

I married a non-Jew, so we have a tree, but it is a purely secular sort of tree. Decorated in a different manner every year, no traditions to pull me down.
 
My oh-so-Jewish 13-yo DD has been lobbying for a silver "Hanukkah bush" that she can decorate with blue balls (of course, NOT what that sounds like!). So far, we've held out, but I'd love to find some tiny table-top sort of thing for her, I guess. And I always take call at the hospital at Christmas, along with my Moslem co-worker.
 
Post a Comment